Subscribe Free Trial Sponsor Advertise

Calif. Appeals Court Rejects Open-Media Rule in Los Angeles

The California Court of Appeals has invalidated a blanket order in Los Angeles that allowed for eased media access to family court proceedings.

The order, issued in 2012 by Presiding Judge of the Juvenile Court Michael Nash, permitted reporters to attend family court proceedings unless any participant successfully argued that the media’s presence and subsequent coverage would harm children involved in the proceedings.

Nash’s decision drew criticism from child welfare advocates, and mixed emotions from youths involved in the system.

The appeals court for the Second Appellate District ruled today that the order violates a section of the state’s Welfare and Institutions Code that governs decision-making about who can attend a hearing.

From the opinion:

“The blanket order interferes with the discretion section 346 vests in the court to determine, on a case-by-case basis, whether a person may be admitted to the hearing based on a ‘direct and legitimate interest in the particular case or the work of the court.’”

Nash had argued to the appeals court that his order was not appealable because it did not “substantially affect the rights of the parties with regard to the disposition.” But the appeals court called that a “misreading of Code of Civil Procedure.”

Click here to read the opinion.

John Kelly is the editor-in-chief of The Chronicle of Social Change.

TAGS: child welfare, Court, dependency court, family court, foster care, juvenile court, Michael Nash


  1. May 22, 2014, 2:16 pm

    [...] court overturns ruling favoring media access to child welfare cases in [...]


Related Content

Kamala Harris’ Bureau of Children’s Justice Takes Shape

On Feb. 12, California Attorney General Kamala Harris held a press conference in Los Angeles...

Pay-for-Success Watch: The Cleveland Case Study

As part of The Chronicle’s continuing coverage of the say-for-success (PFS) funding model emerging in...

Storytelling Can Change the World

Before becoming a mental health advocate, I worked in East Africa. I had been chosen...

Getting to the Heart of Foster Children’s Problems

This article is adapted from an earlier piece that ran in the San Jose Mercury...